I think contra should stay in. If it scares off lamers, I am OK with that and eventually, more and more people will become regulars and get to know the map and thus stay on.
Personally, I think Villa needs the boot. Port should be removed (even though I LOVE IT) and can come on via mapvote if enough people want to play.
Prodigy is fun, but can get worn out quick. Maybe just lower the frequency.
Nuke, Aztec, Cbbl, Tides, Italy, Piranesi, Inferno are all musts.
Boot 3rd st and pick either CPL Mill or Clan Mill.
Train is 'meh'