I guess this is as good a thread as any to chime in on. You guys know I don't pay for a membership; I have my reasons which I'm not going to get into in this thread. Lately your L4D2 server feels like you have to pay for a membership to even stand a chance at playing there during a 6-8 hour chunk of the day. I understand your kick system and it's a pretty standard system just like in every other game. The difference with L4D is that games last about 1-2 hours. It's not really like other FPS games where each round is essentially a brand new game. I know a lot of the members around here say to the people who don't have membership that they should just "suck it up" and pay the $15 a year. Well, if you're telling people that they need to pay money or get kicked then what you're describing is extortion so maybe you should be a little more considerate with your posts and enjoy the benefits of your membership instead. I find it hilarious and disgraceful that you're having an argument over how to divvy up the points of someone who gets kicked so that you can have the privilege of playing immediately.
My issue with the system you're using isn't that it kicks people to make room for members, it's that in a server that takes such a long time to get into and with games lasting as long as they do there are times where the same member will repeatedly kick the same person. People also have a lot more invested into the game than they do a round of Counter-Strike so when they're kicked mid-round it's a pretty big deal. I saw dryfire get kicked about 5 times in a row one night because someone would join for five minutes, have some sort of computer issue, disconnect, and then join back in again five minutes later. It's pretty much impossible for a non-member to take a quick break to use the restroom without losing their spot but I frequently see members go AFK in spectate for a few minutes while some poor sap holds their survivor for them so a bot doesn't get it killed.
You guys seem to be pulling in something to the tune of 10-20 members a week these days so I kinda figured you'd already be in talks about making a second server. I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that some of your reasons for not making one immediately are that new membership rates will slow down as demand for slots decreases and the second server won't be as popular because the regulars won't want to be split across servers. Then there's all the logistics of transitioning the kick system into one that moves people to the other server or something of the sort, who to move, how to deal with member access to a full server, etc. Frankly, I wouldn't be surprised if you guys choose to just stick with one server. As such, the kicking thing is going to continue to be an issue.
Anyways, my point in all this... I've stopped playing on your server. This is the second time I've done so; the first was because the team stacking was getting out of control and this time it's because of the kick system. I've been playing on GC servers for a very long time but playing on the L4D2 server without a membership has just been too difficult lately. I have some ideas for what you guys could do with it but I understand that you have to cater to your donating members first and foremost so I don't expect the system to really change at all. I'm sure all the admins know of the issues and have had extensive talks about it but a lot of the community members seem to take their membership for granted and look down on people who don't pay. Session, I guarantee many of the non-paying people around GC servers have given a lot more to the community than you have so you really need to re-think some of the stuff you've said. Just because you gave them $15 (and I really doubt you considered it a "donation" when you did) does not make you better than people who haven't. Good day.
P.S. Flitter how have I not run into you before?